Free shipping over $99  ✦  Made to order  ✦  Secure checkout  ✦  Covered if damaged

TRAVEL BLOG

Best Bagels in NYC: What to Order and How to Eat It

Plain New York style bagel
Plain New York style bagel
Photo: Wikimedia Commons (free to use)

A real New York bagel is chewy inside, shiny and slightly crisp outside, and never doughy. If you are hunting for the best bagels in NYC, here is what to know before you stand in line.

What makes a New York bagel special

Traditional bagels are boiled briefly before baking, which creates the shiny crust and dense, chewy texture. The best shops make them fresh every morning, so go early.

What to order

  • Everything bagel with cream cheese, the classic.
  • Bagel with lox, which is cream cheese, smoked salmon, red onion and capers.
  • Egg and cheese on a bagel, the classic New York breakfast.
  • A plain bagel, the simplest way to judge a shop.

How to spot a great bagel shop

  • A line out the door in the morning.
  • Bagels baked fresh and sold the same day.
  • A good spread of cream cheese flavors made in house.

Pair it with a walk

Grab a bagel and walk through the West Village or Brooklyn Heights. Add it to day three of our NYC itinerary, or try our pizza guide for lunch. And explore our Grand Central Terminal wall art, a tribute to a city that runs on breakfast on the go.

SHOP THE LOOK

Take New York home

Pinterest
Facebook
Email
NEWSLETTER

Get new guides

One email when a new guide goes up.

TRAVEL BLOG

Keep reading